February 2010

 

February 2010. 1

Cleaning IBC’s. 1

Is Cider Making Agriculture?. 2

A Belated Wassail 4

David vs. Goliath. 6

 

Cleaning IBC’s

 

At the beginning of the year Con asked if anyone knew of a power washer, with a lance, the jet of which could be rotated through 180 degrees. Such a device would facilitate the cleaning of IBC tanks. This struck a chord with some more of us in the group who had also wished that there was an efficient tool for the awkward job of cleaning the underside of the top of these tanks. It was a problem that had caused me to make modifications to my own pressure washer, none of which had proved satisfactory. 

Barry and I discussed this by phone after the series of Workshop posts. He had known various gadgets for tank and barrel cleaning including a neat little stainless 'spray ball' that would spray jets in all directions, once placed inside a tank. On my part I have found that an ordinary pressure washer works well for IBCs. I particularly like the fact that the full pressure can be selectively brought to bear, on any places where a stubborn build up of yeast has accumulated. If only it were possible to bend the lance so that the powerful jet of water could get up into the lumpy areas under the top of the tank. These areas usually harbour a lot of dross thrown up from the foam of the fermentation and can become difficult to keep clean. 

Not long after this I received an email from Barry saying that he had found the ideal thing. He had located a supplier of specialist attachments for pressure washers called Clean Break Ltd. They sell an adjustable swivel attachment, designed to fit on the end of the lance. It is made of stainless steel and is adjustable over an arc of 240 degrees. Once the angle has been set, it is locked by the water pressure when the washer is in use. Clever! (stops it inadvertently squirting you in the eye). The device costs £25.50 including VAT. 

I have just bought one of these and have found it to be just what I wanted. However I also had to buy a lance and a nozzle to go with it, as my existing lance is incompatible. All in all it cost £61 including VAT & postage. Nevertheless all is in stainless and well made in Germany. I consider it money well spent as I am so pleased to have solved the IBC cleaning problem at last. Hygiene in cidermaking always repays every pound spent! 

Clean Break recommend the swivel as being ideal for cleaning out gutters, whilst standing on the ground below. One holds the lance vertically with the nozzle pointing downwards at 45 degrees into the guttering. Unlike the well contained cleaning of the IBCs, I imagine this could be a messy experience! Clean Break Ltd. may be emailed on clean or ring 01677 424967 and ask for Jason French. 

Thank you Barry, for this very useful lead. 

Rose


Is Cider Making Agriculture?

 


This may be of interest to those of us who are producing commercially. 

Today I inadvertently discovered something that answers questions that I have never dared to ask!!! Is a small scale commercial cidermaking subject to business rates? Do I need to apply for change of use for the barn I use for cidermaking?

agri1.gifThe key to these questions is whether cidermaking is an agricultural activity. Agriculture is exempt from business rates. I have never applied for change of use for the barn. It used to house livestock, so is still nominally 'agricultural'. If cidermaking is agricultural, then I should be in the clear.

This morning I was in Dorchester to speak in support of a local cidermaking family at their planning appeal. The need arose during the course of the meeting to define the commercial status of cidermaking. It transpired that the subject had become a 'cause celebre' in 1999 in what was known as the Millington Case, where a High Court judgement against a farmer in favour of Shrewsbury Council was overturned by the Court of Appeal. 

The Millington Case concerned a farmer who had planted vines on one third of his farm. Wine was produced and sold from the farm. The case had enforced a change of use, on the grounds that the sale of wine and light refreshments by fee paying members of the public was material. However, The Court of Appeal stated that the correct approach was to consider the activities of the appellant and whether they were incidental to the growing of grapes, ancillary to normal farming activities and reasonably necessary to make the product marketable. It was held that the production of wine or cider on the scale of the appellant's business was found to be perfectly normal. 

The appeal decision has shown that where farm processing is not on a large scale it could be considered ancillary to agriculture. 

Further to this, it would also appear that if you have a farm shop selling only the cider made on your farm, it too would qualify as 'ancillary to agriculture'. 

Interesting, isn't it? 

I'm breathing a little easier today! 

Rose 

Very interesting Rose. I wonder if this could also be seen in the context of the 70 hL HMRC exemption too. For those under that limit the business is clearly ancillary since it was always intended that such a level of activity could not form the basis of a viable living on its own. But once over the limit, other considerations might come into play if the business made enough money to pay a genuine living wage to someone? 

Andrew

 

Guys, 

After seeing Rose's comments I would definitely have a go at your council regarding the rates,we are under a yet more beaurocratic regime down here in the New Forest namely a national park authority, I'm keeping my head down although having been established 22 years, I've recently seen a fellow winemaker nearby nearly stopped in his tracks with his farm shop stocking all locally produced products, this seems completely irrational to me within the ethos of shopping local ,cutting food miles and local terroir etc, beaurocracy has gone mad, as he said in his appeal the vineyard shop was not viable solely on tourist wine tastings just in the summer season. 

Barry Topp 

 

Barry, 

I think you have just illustrated the main thrust of the Millington argument. Your local winemaker was in fact running a farm shop selling a variety of bought in products. Farm shops are liable to business rates ( one near here that sells my cider told me how crippling the payments are!). The important thing highlighted by the Millington appeal was that selling wine or cider, made from your own grapes or apples, from your own premises, was deemed to be 'ancillary to agriculture'. The Shrewsbury Council had thought otherwise and won the support of the High Court, but the judgment was overruled by the Court of Appeal. 

If Guy is only selling his own cider made from the apples grown on his farm, then that same ruling must apply. The Millington Appeal has established a precedent that unless repealed, has become the Law of the Land. All county councils in England must therefore comply. Of course, I'm no expert but I do think it would be worthwhile for Guy to talk to a solicitor about it. It may be that he is in a strong position to take that unpleasant and threatening council to task, with very little risk of losing the argument. 

Rose 

 


A Belated Wassail

 


We intended to hold our wassail on the second Saturday in January but decided it would be wise to cancel it. We were then experiencing an unusually cold spell. Although the snow fall in Dorset was light compared with the rest of the country, our roads here were treacherous. The local authority has never considered the little single track road to our village worthy of some salt and grit; in spite of its course being mostly just a few feet from the edge of a stream. I had visions of unfortunate happenings to our wassailers, many of whom come from as far afield as Bournemouth. 

That seemed to be it, for this year. The following two Saturdays were taken up by kind invitations from our friend's, firstly to a wassail and then to a Burns Night supper. Nevertheless it seemed sad not to have had our wassail and several people said how much they had missed it. I realised that there was still one Saturday left in January, the weather had now become more reasonable, so we decided to give it a go. Too bad, that by then it would be 25 th night and far removed from 'Old 12th', but who cares, we are not superstitious! 

It proved to be a good decision. Saturday 30th was perfect, the very best weather conditions of any wassail held here to date. The orchard was white with frost and well illuminated by a full moon. Best of all, there was hardly a breath of wind. It has never been so easy to light the candle lanterns. These are the sort that contain the 'nightlight' refills and we position them at intervals to mark the way from the village road. Usually we also hang the little lanterns from as many of the orchard trees as possible to create a festive effect. However, this year I wanted to try a special orchard illumination idea, as used in the Three Counties; the spectacular flaming logs. 

wassail2010.gifI had seen some remarkable pictures of the flaming log flares on the internet. I'd also learnt that they were made by using a chainsaw to make deep cuts longitudinally at the business end of each log. The cuts were in the form of two crosses making a Union Jack pattern and to a depth of about 18 inches. Barry kindly agreed to get me some 4 ft silver birch logs from the New Forest, these being readily available from the forester's weeding out operations. Apparently the birches prolifically set seed from the wooded to the marshland areas. Every so often these seedling trees have to be felled to maintain the status quo. Barry had to wait for the ground to be deeply frozen before he could take his tractor out on to the marsh to collect the logs. He selected some that were just the right size, being about 6 inches diameter. Once back in the yard at New Forest Cider, he thoughtfully did the special chainsaw surgery as well. All I had to do was to go over and collect the logs in the Landrover. Many thanks, Barry! 

A few days before the event, I experimented with two of Barry's logs in our garden. I wanted to find the best manner of lighting and how long it took the flare to reach its peak performance. Contrary to expectations I found that household fire lighter blocks did not work very well. It was difficult to work them down far enough into the chainsaw grooves. Even having done so, they then did not burn very well and the log never really got going. The best lighter eventually proved to be the time honoured paraffin rag. I found a refinement of the technique was to use some of those highly absorbent microfibre kitchen cloths. These were doubled and squeezed well down into the grooves; following which the logs were liberally dowsed with paraffin. This method worked a treat. I timed the burn and found that the flare peaked at around about one hour after lighting and then burnt well for a further half an hour. Light up time would therefore need to be 6 pm for the 7 pm wassail. 

Eight of the logs were positioned to encircle the wassail tree. They were set at about a 30 yd radius so that there was ample room for the spectators to gather around the tree. Our King tree was picked out by generator powered halogen floodlights; its branches decorated with strings of white LEDs. By 7 pm the log flares were all crackling and blazing really well. The overall effect was certainly pleasing and worth all the effort involved. 

The full moon dominated the clear starry sky so I could see the people coming across the adjoining field. Soon I could hear the excited sound of their chatter as they caught sight of the fiery scene that lay ahead. As they entered the orchard there came the crunchiness sound of many feet on the frozen grass. There was a sense of excitement as I handed out the song sheets and also an unusual air of mystery. Everyone had their hats on, each so firmly pulled down as protection from the cold that I found it difficult to recognise even dear friends that I know well. This was a trifle embarrassing but it was good to see that all had come well wrapped up. In fact the wassail2010a.gifcold night air did not seem to matter at all. The fiddlers struck up merrily and the Houghton Wassail was sung louder and better than ever before. 

Our little ceremony proceeded in the traditional manner and concluded with some further fiddle assisted singing to the tune of the Gloucester Wassail. It was especially nice this year to welcome a new family to the village and I was delighted that their children had agreed to do the gifts. Megan climbed on a little stool and sweetly placed the toast in the tree, then Henry her little brother enjoyed splashing the cider all around it from a half gallon jar. Someone told me later that the family, who had moved here from Essex, had been amazed to find these weird goings on in their new village! 

Afterwards, back at the cottage, the mulled cider was a popular warmer- upper. Whether it was due to the cold night or my new recipe, I'm not sure, but it did seem to be extra yummy this year. For those who may be interested, this year's version was made of 4 gallons of new cider, to which was added a bottle of orange squash, a bottle of lemonade, two bottles of cheap brandy, half a bottle of Bacardi, 2 lbs of demerara sugar with mixed spice and ginger added to taste during the brewing. It was surprising how quickly a Burco full of this hot product could be emptied by our cheery band of wassailers! This welcoming drink was of course just a starter, soon followed by a good variety of food, much of which had been kindly donated by our guests. I had put a couple of B-in-Bs of the new Cider by Rosie on the kitchen table in order to keep the party going and to lubricate our later 'sing along' by the fireside. The cider had worried me because it was still so young, so it was a relief to find folk were enjoying it and even passing favourable comments. Further satisfaction came when I found there was only a litre or two left, the following morning! 

It was such a happy evening and Frances and I were both pleased that we had gone ahead and put it on, despite the earlier cancellation. 

Rose

 


David vs. Goliath

 


Like many pubs these days, the management of our Local has changed hands every few years. The two landlords, previous to our present one, both tried to persuade Ringwood Brewery to let them sell my draught cider. They asked for a special exemption from the tie, due to my cider's local provenance and the fact that the customers wanted to drink it. At one point a number of the regular customers also made representations to the brewery for this favour to be granted. None of these approaches met with success.

We now have a new landlord and landlady who have already improved things all round. Not only is the pub better managed, it is neater, cleaner and produces excellent meals. Instead of a couple of draught ales,( if you were lucky), there are now four or five with a variety of guest beers. One thing however remains doggedly the same, as it has for many years; the only draught cider available is Thatchers. 

In the meantime the pub's ownership has also changed, since the Ringwood brewery was bought up by mighty Marston's PLC. Down at the less exalted level of our pub bar, some thought that the much larger concern could possibly afford to be magnanimous. After all, what difference could such a small concession, in just one of their 500+ pubs, make to the business as a whole? Our keen new landlord was fired up to make another approach to the new Goliath! 

When I saw him last week he was sad and apologetic. He assured me that he had tried really hard to get Marstons to relax their position on the cider tie. He had even persisted, more so I think than his predecessors, insisting that his request reached their top management. In spite of all, the reply had come back that nothing could be done, since it was a 'contractural matter'. I asked how it was that our pub could have so many different guest beers. Apparently in every case, the breweries that make them are also owned by Marstons! 

I had hoped that Marstons could have lent over just a little, to encourage a small local business. My hopes had been based on an example I came across in Much Marcle. There the tied pub in the middle of the village has a special exemption to sell Westons because their cider is made only half a mile up the road. Then of course, Westons is not a small local business! 

There is something clearly wrong with these monopolistic big business outfits that control so many of our pubs. They are incapable of seeing things at ground level. Such blatant anti competitiveness is surely neither good for the pubs, nor even ultimately to the corporate good of their owners. 

Last year I entered into an email discussion with the landlord of a free house that I hoped to supply. Initially he took the attitude of, why should he buy my cider when the Stowford Press on his bar came in considerably cheaper. My reply was that success it is not just about the perceived profit from one cider versus another, rather it is more to do with the number of customers attracted to the pub. I suggested that if he were to put on a craft cider, 'word would get round' and the level of business would increase. After a few days he decided to buy a box and give it a try. I'm glad to say that my words came true. The pub did really well with its craft cider all through the summer and now regularly has a selection of five or more West Country craft ciders available. 

Rose